When do the Rules Apply?

by | Nov 9, 2012 | Insurance Restoration & Claims, Safe Practices, The Law | 0 comments

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Over Toasted Explorer

A client of mine had a fire in a carport. It was sad, her Ford Explorer caught  fire spontaneously and set her carport ablaze. It was a freak situation, one of those cars that was eventually recalled because of  a faulty cruise control. The fire department was able to save the structure but the lid was a total loss and it sustained  charring of the beams.

The rules on charring, according to Perry Paine of the Boise City Building Department, are “It is always safe to say that if substantial charring has penetrated the member more than 1/4″ that member should be calc’d to determine if loading would exceed the capacity of the reduced member size.”

Perry went on to say, “that rule of thumb works well for columns and beams.” Trusses on the other hand, need a little more detailed inspection and analysis.  With those it really doesn’t take an expert to determine “if in doubt, throw it out.”  I do however recommend truss repair in certain instances.  It depends on how the fire damages the truss and how extensive the damage is. A design professional (IE: building inspector and / or structural engineer), needs to inspect if major columns, beams, or trusses have sustained damage.  A framed wall or engineered floor system however is a different case. If they replace the charred members and rebuild as it was.” Remember, there may be other serious issues of under engineering that existed prior to the fire like an undersized beam (prior to the fire,) as in our case.

Lightly Charred Beam

Years ago, while rebuilding the burned out shell of a building to turn it into a restaurant, the city made us remove all of the smoke damaged lumber. Their reasoning was that “They didn’t want anyone to smell smoke and yell fire!”

Our client was under the impression for several years that she was required to remove the structure entirely. That meant she was required to follow the new setback requirements, which was an unattractive option.

When I evaluated the project, I realized that all she needed was a repair. That, in turn, allowed her to rebuild and utilize most of the existing beam and post structure. After consulting with the building department, we all agreed that the rules are in place to protect the public and to ensure that rebuilding a charred structure is evaluated on a case by case basis. In our situation, I was correct. We were able to rebuild upon the existing supporting structure using a grandfathered size, ultimately saving my client thousands of dollars.

Saving the Foundations

From an insurance perspective, this is not the first time Levco has had to get involved where the owner is under insured for replacement of an unattached structure. Seems like insurance companies like to automatically assign a percentage like 10% of your home’s value to the detached structures.

In closing, here is a little To-Do for you today…call your agent and make sure your out buildings are adequately insured. Make sure the conversation heads in the direction of replacement values and they will get the point. Don’t forget, contents are valuable too. While you are at it, go take some photos of the stuff you have and store it somewhere safe or send it to your agent.

Your comments are welcome. To ask questions or get more information about remodeling, email me directly or visit our contact page.

Disclaimer: Some of these images came from the WEB. If they are yours, and you object to them being used, please claim them and I will gladly remove and replace them at once.

Disclaimer: Some of these images came from the WEB. If they are yours, and you object to them being used, please claim them and I will gladly remove and replace them at once.

Related Posts

Holy Cow! We Do Amazing Work

Holy Cow! We Do Amazing Work

As a business owner, doing all the behind-the-scenes things is often so time-consuming that I honestly "Don't get out much." It took a friendly reminder, and now I have a scheduled tour de force every Wednesday with my Construction Manager. We ride around and look at...

read more
Building Science and Remodeling

Building Science and Remodeling

As a residential remodeler for a few decades after being a paramedic for a little longer,  I have learned to take command of a situation and solve problems quickly and efficiently. I have been able to watch the evolution of Building Science. It affects every aspect of...

read more

Leave A Comment

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

Categories

Latest Projects

Master Suite Addition

Master Suite Addition

Master Suite AdditionThe Challenge They came up with a plan drawn by others with several significant errors. One was the size of the addition, and the other was the angle of the trusses. The clients who work remotely turned out to be excellent communicators and...

Dining Room Addition and Kitchen Remodel

Dining Room Addition and Kitchen Remodel

Dining Room Addition and Kitchen RemodelThe Challenge The home had an odd entry room with a coat closet and partition wall in the way. This room was pretty useless and annoying to the client. Then, the kitchen was blocked from the activity in the living room, and the...

Primary Suite Remodel with Deck

Primary Suite Remodel with Deck

Primary Suite Remodel & DeckThe Challenge Inaccurate plans were provided that had to get updated over the course of the project. The project is on a creek so lots of precautions were needed to keep erosion out of it.  The Idea Create a primary suite that is...

Whole House Remodel

Whole House Remodel

Whole House RemodelThe Challenge The home was in the hillside district and in the WUI which means that the home has some extra requirements as far as firesafe and extra structural requirements. There had been an addition done to the house years prior that was not...